Some of these are discussed in the second part together with empirical data showing. So i will only touch on those differences briefly here. Criterion referenced test construction and evaluation. The paper then describes an empirical investigation to determine the usefulness of this procedure. Analyze the items carefully using item format analysis to make sure they are wellwritten and.
In their system an item form was comprised of a complete set of rules for generating a domain of items. An external criterion is required to accurately judge the validity of test items. Critics of criterion referenced tests point out that judges set bookmarks around items of varying difficulty without considering whether the items actually are compliant with grade level content standards or are developmentally appropriate. This paper describes major concepts related to item analysis for criterion referenced tests including validity, reliability, item difficulty, and item discrimination. When conducting an item analysis the item difficulty, item discrimination, and distractor quality should all be considered.
Criterionreferenced interpretation is the interpretation of a test score as a measure of the knowledge, skills, and abilities an individual or group can demonstrate from. What techniques can be devised which will permit objectivebased test developers to improve their instruments on the basis of empirical tryouts in the same ways that conventional test developers have been doing for years e. By using the internal criterion of total test score, item analyses reflect internal consistency of items rather than validity. Use test analysis results to determine the need for test item revision. This paper describes major concepts related to item analysis for criterionreferenced tests including validity, reliability, item difficulty, and item discrimination, particularly in relation to criterion referenced tests. In other words, the criterion reference test is a set of fixed criteria. This claim is discussed and the case is made that interpretations and uses of criterionreferenced tests require sup. Two forms of a 25item multiplechoicecriterion referenced vocabulary test were developed and administered to two groups of community secondary school obigwe in rivers state of nigeria n87 for diagnostic and achievement purposes in a counter balanced. The problem of criterion referenced scoring and score interpretation, the problem of criterion referenced item and test analysis, and the problem of mastery decisions.
They are those that are constructed and interpreted according to a specific set of learning outcome. Formula for the pointbiserial coeffiecient for determining item validity. Item analysis table of contents major uses of item analysis item analysis reports item analysis response patterns basic item analysis statistics interpretation of basic statistics other item statistics summary data report options item analysis guidelines major uses of item analysis item analysis can be a powerful technique available to instructors for the guidance and. It discusses the assumptions of the two models and how these assumptions can affect criterionreferenced test construction and interpretation. A preliminary item analysis was conducted after test administrations using all candidate score data n 1,493. Choosing item statistics and item analysis techniques 255. This paper describes major concepts related to item analysis for criterionreferenced tests including validity, reliability, item difficulty, and item discrimination, particularly in relation to. Criterion referenced exam results compares individuals against a standard or set of criteria may or may not produce a bellshaped curve the graph of test results is provided by several commercial packages. Item analysis concepts are similar for normreferenced and criterionref erenced tests, but they differ in. Item analysis concepts are similar for norm referenced and criterion referenced tests, but they differ in specific, significant ways. Using remark statistics for test reliability and item analysis. This paper describes major concepts related to item analysis for criterion referenced tests including validity, reliability, item difficulty, and item discrimination, particularly in relation to criterion referenced tests. Content validity is important for criterion referenced measures, but it is not sufficient.
Most tests and quizzes that are written by school teachers can be considered criterionreferenced tests. For criterion referenced tests crts, with their emphasis on masterytesting, many items on an exam form will have pvalues of. This paper is on criterion referenced test construction and evaluation. This type of test is useful for measuring the mastery of that subject. Criterion referenced tests are designed to find out whether a child has a set of skills, rather than how a child compares to other children of the same age normed tests. Cox and vargas 1966 con trasted normreferenced item analysis with the criterion version. Others have followed as dictated by federal and state laws. In addition, item analysis is valuable for increasing instructors skills in test construction, and identifying specific areas of course. It investigates the performance of items considered individually either in relation to some external criterion or in relation to the remaining items on the test thompson. Criterion criterionreferenced item analysis referenced item. With criterion referenced tests, use norm referenced statistics for. Some advantages and disadvantages for science instruction. In this case, the objective is simply to see whether the student has learned. It uses this information to improve item and test quality.
To determine the validity of an individual test item, we correlate the scores on that test item with the external criterion from the domain of interest. Generally, students are expected to do much better than chance because they have been. The first statewide criterion referenced testing took place with the minimum performance testing, the high school exit exam, and then actaap began in 1998 with grade 4 reading, writing and mathematics that was designed to align with the arkansass curriculum frameworks. Criterion referenced test crt constructed to yield measurements that are directly interpretable in terms of specific performance standards performance standards are generally specified by defining a class or domain of tasks that should be performed by the participant. Criterion reference test is a method which uses test score to judge students. The dependability indexes for these tests were low or moderate and an item analysis of the criterionreference tests suggests there was a slight. Eric ed501716 item analysis for criterionreferenced. Two forms of a 25 item multiplechoice criterion referenced vocabulary test were developed and administered to two groups of community secondary school obigwe in rivers state of nigeria n87 for diagnostic and achievement purposes in a counter balanced. Items on norm referenced tests need to discriminate between high and low performers because those tests are generally used to make aptitude, proficiency or. These results are usually pass or fail and are used in. Identifies distractors not doing what they are supposed to do. If an item is too easy, too difficult, failing to show a difference between skilled and unskilled examinees, or even scored incorrectly, an item analysis will reveal it. The goal with these tests is to determine whether or not the candidate has the demonstrated mastery of a certain skill or set of skills.
This claim is discussed and the case is made that interpretations and uses of criterion referenced tests require sup. Download fulltext pdf application of item response models to criterionreferenced assessment article pdf available in applied psychological measurement 71. Normreferenced item analysis referenced item analysis jalt. Criterion referenced interpretation is the interpretation of a test score as a measure of the knowledge, skills, and abilities an individual or group can demonstrate from a clearly defined content or behavior domain. The study then specifically examines how the indices operate in terms of item discrimination when.
Feb 05, 2016 thus diagnostic tests should be criterion referenced. Criterionreferenced test definition the glossary of. I have discussed the major differences between normreferenced and criterionreferenced tests in a number of places most recently in brown, 2012a. Thus diagnostic tests should be criterion referenced. An item is a basic building block of a test, and its analysis provides information about its performance. Normreferenced and criterionreferenced test in efl. Item analysis examples so, a test item may have an item difficulty of. Criterionreferenced tests and assessments are designed to measure student performance against a fixed set of predetermined criteria or learning standards i. Interpret test analysis results to determine test item level of difficulty p and discrimination d. Criterion referenced exam results compares individuals against a standard or set of criteria may or may not produce a bellshaped curve the graph of test. I have also explained at length the different strategies that should be applied in developing and validating the.
In this phase statistical methods are used to identify any test items that are not working well. The only danger to criterion referencing from item analysis is if bad items are omitted, thus leaving holes in the representation of the domain. Criterionreferenced test vs normreferenced test meaning. Item analysis is the set of qualitative and quantitative techniques and procedures used to evaluate the characteristics of items of the test before and after the test development and construction. The discrimination index is not always a measure of item quality. Eric ed099427 a collection of criterionreferenced tests.
Approaches to language testing normreferenced test and criterionreferenced test are the language testing approaches that provide information about the knowledge and skills of the students tested. Criterionreferenced test reliability university ofhawaii. A single test to fulfill all test functions there is no single test that can fulfill all four functions of proficiency, placement, achievement, and diagnostic because. In elementary and secondary education, criterionreferenced tests are used to evaluate whether students. Understanding item analyses office of educational assessment. While test items can be analyzed on both criterion referenced and norm referenced tests, the analysis is somewhat different because the purpose of the two types of tests is different. Interpret test analysis results to determine overall test performance. The problem of criterionreferenced scoring and score interpretation, the problem of criterionreferenced item and test analysis, and the problem of. I have discussed the major differences between norm referenced and criterion referenced tests in a number of places most recently in brown, 2012a. Item analysis conducting an item analysis following an administration of your assessment is important to identify any questions that are not perfo rming well due to inappropriate difficulty, scoring error, or other factors. Item analysis data are not synonymous with item validity. Normreferenced and criterionreferenced test in efl classroom.
Criterionreferenced tests or crts differ in that each examinees performance is compared to a predefined set of criteria or a standard. Content validity is important for criterionreferenced measures, but it is not sufficient. With criterionreferenced tests, use normreferenced statistics for. Grade 8 criterion referenced testing followed in the spring of 1999, with field testing for grade 6, end of course for algebra i and geometry and end of level grade 11 literacy which began in 2000. Multiple choice items, openresponse items, and writing prompts. Different ways criterionreferenced tests are made commercial products ripa criterionreferenced assessment it is standardized with procedures but does not compare to normative data published measures comparing to a norm, checklists, functional independence measure, sz ratio for voice, breathing patterns for voice, checklist for limb. Criterionreferenced tests are designed to find out whether a child has a set of skills, rather than how a child compares to other children of the same age normed tests. The tests cited are the result of an attempt made to bring together tests designated in the educational testing service test collection, a library of tests and test related information, and labeled in the eric system as criterion referenced tests. Criterionreferenced test crt constructed to yield measurements that are directly interpretable in terms of specific performance standards performance standards are generally specified by defining a class or domain of tasks that should be performed by the participant.
The tests cited are the result of an attempt made to bring together tests designated in the educational testing service test collection, a library of tests and test related information, and labeled in the eric system as criterionreferenced tests. Application of item response models to criterionreferenced. The paper discussed how these concepts can be used to revise and improve items and listed suggestions regarding general guidelines for test development. Statewide assessment program information guide 201920. Criterionreferenced assessments flashcards quizlet. Norm referenced tests nrts, on the other hand, are designed to be harder overall and to spread out the examinees scores. The item analysis is an important phase in the development of an exam program. Best for norm referenced tests comparing students within a group, not against a criterion. An absolute standard of performance is set for grading purposes. Introduction the item analysis is an important phase in the development of an exam program.
Item analysis concepts are similar for normreferenced and criterion referenced tests, but they differ in specific, significant ways. Questions and answers about language testing statistics. Florida journal of educational research, 351, 5462. One result was a recently published article brown 1989 which discussed criterion referenced test development techniques. The test designers analyze the component parts of specific academic skills, such as number understanding, and then write test items that will measure whether the child has. This means that 70% of the test takers passed the item, and more students in the top group than the bottom group got the item correct. I have also explained at length the different strategies that should be. Statewide assessment program information guide 3 2. It discusses the assumptions of the two models and how these assumptions can affect criterion referenced test construction and interpretation. Critics of criterionreferenced tests point out that judges set bookmarks around items of varying difficulty without considering whether the items actually are compliant with grade level content standards or are developmentally appropriate.
The ranges of ability tested by the four types of tests are very different. Item analysis statistics for criterionreferenced tests. Best for normreferenced tests comparing students within a group, not against a criterion. Also, they help to generate statements about students behavior. Criterionreferenced interpretation sage research methods. Pdf criterionreferenced test administration designs and analyses.
1021 853 539 496 931 658 349 1079 517 892 1208 285 988 1551 1271 178 61 923 1042 1303 1523 675 116 1178 1125 1058 360 437 926 868 680 1309